He is just a terribly untalented idiot. He sounds like a caveman.

Not at all.

now that I've actually seen his films (Magic Mike, 21/22 Jump Street, and Foxcatcher) I actually think he is quite talented.

He seems like a very nice guy (like Hitler) and a pretty decent actor.

I like him. He's a solid dramatic actor and has great comic timing.

Yep. A one dimensional bore, with minimal acting ability. He seems to have a brooding presence that appeals to the mainstream audience. Movie wise, I like SIDE EFFECTS, but that's it. Yet to see FOXCATCHER.

His action and drama, great.
Comedy and romance, not as good, but still not terrible.

I thought he was great in Foxcatcher. Haven't seen much else from him except for Side Effects and 21 Jump Street.

I like him in She's The Man.

Oh, how could you compare him to a caveman? Caveman were pretty smart and solid people.

His voice is a great actor. His face is another story (but its so dreamy...).